RS 2477 Home                County Map                Criteria                History               Sources                Relevant Documents

Butterfield Canyon

The Road

The Butterfield Canyon claim begins to the west of Herriman at the foot of the Oquirrh Mountains.  The claim extends from the mouth of Butterfield Canyon to the top of the ridge, the boundary between Salt Lake and Tooele County. 

 Shortly after splitting off of Highway 71, the Butterfield Canyon claim passes through a large yellow gate.  The gate remains open if the road is passable, but will often be closed during the winter months, depending on the condition of the road.  The first portion of the claim is a wide, well maintained road that travels through federal and private lands.  After going approximately half way up the canyon, as the road leaves the canyon bottom and begins to climb the hillside, it becomes significantly narrower.  As you approach the ridge, about a mile before the end of the claim, the pavement ends.  From this point on, with the exception of a few stretches where some wash-boarding has occurred, the claim is a relatively well maintained dirt road.  At the top of the ridge, and the end of the claim, there is room to park several cars.  Hikers, horseback riders, and off-road vehicle users can access several trails from this area.  The road can be followed from the top of the ridge down into Tooele or along another branch that splits off and runs along the ridge a short distance.

Back to the Top

Criteria*

"The right-of-way for the construction of highways over the public lands not reserved for public uses, is hereby granted."

Construction:  "Means an intentional physical act or series of intentional physical acts that were intended to, and that accomplished, preparation of a highway by a durable, observable, physical modification of land for use by highway traffic." 

The road in Butterfield Canyon is paved for the majority of its length.  As it approaches the ridgeline the pavement ends; however, evidence of road construction continues as the road is cut into the hillside as it climbs out of the canyon bottom.

Highway: "Means a thoroughfare that was prior to the latest available date used by the public, without discrimination against any individual or group, for the passage of vehicles carrying people or goods from place to place."

This road is open to the public when conditions are safe and the road is passable.  It connects the southwestern part of Salt Lake County to the city of Tooele.

Unreserved public lands:  "lands owned by the United States...that had not yet been set aside, dedicated, withdrawn, reserved, settled, preempted, entered, appropriated, or disposed of, or on which claims had not been located."

It is likely that this road was constructed early in the 1900's, probably predating any reservation.

(*Definitions are taken directly from “The Revised Statute (R.S.) 2477 Rights-of-Way Act.”)

Back to the Top

History

There is little detailed information that exists about the early history of the Oquirrh Mountains.  However, it is known that the early Mormon Settlers in the area came to this mountain range in search of a lumber source in the mid 1800’s.  Around the turn of the century several deposits of lead, silver and gold were found.  As happened in the Wasatch Mountains, this led to a significant amount of mining and prospecting in the canyons of the Oquirrh Mountains.  Relative to the neighboring Bingham Canyon, few mining claims where patented in Butterfield Canyon.  Those that were include the Butterfield and the Butterfield Park Placer mining claims.  These claims were located along Butterfield Creek and extended up both sides of the canyon.  The two claims consisted of most of the canyon bottom for the first half of Butterfield Canyon.  It is not clear if the road up the canyon was constructed to allow work to be done on these claims.  Maps from a survey of the area done in the late 1890’s include the area patented for these mining claims, but do not show a road into the canyon.  If a route accessing these claims was being used at the time of the survey, it was not significant enough to be included in these maps.  This would suggest that the fairly substantial route that connects Butterfield Canyon to Tooele County was built sometime in the early 20th century.

Back to the Top

Sources

Coon, Bill.  Past President of the Utah Backcountry Horsemen (currently President of Friends of Sound Horses).  Conversation on August 25, 2005.

Salt Lake County Recorder’s Office. Research of plat maps in area of Butterfield Canyon.  Salt Lake City, UT. August 16, 2005.

Bureau of Land Management (Utah).  Research of mining claim patents.  September 21, 2005.

Salt Lake County Surveyor’s Office.  “The Bible” -  Book of maps, accompanied by a book of field notes (Field Notes of Survey - Hwy No. 124 p. 190).  Surveyed September 1-3, 1898 with field notes recorded in Field Book I p. 60-67.

Back to the Top

Relevant Documents

Map of the Butterfield Canyon Claim

Index of County Roads (pdf 1.5 MB):  An index of Salt Lake County Roads, completed on September 26, 1935.  This list was compiled by the County Recorder and includes Butterfield Canyon, Highway 124.

Back to the Top